Texas Sea Grant title logo  
September 5, 2008
 
Texas Sea Grant Homepage

5. Were the Karankawas “Giants”?

Researcher ________________________________ Research Team _________

By around 8,000 BC, the Pleistocene or Ice Age had ended and the next two thousand years or so are referred to as the Late Paleo-Indian period. The animal life, vegetation and

climates became like those of today, and the lifestyle of the Native

Americans remained the same. They adapted, increased their popula

tions and covered very diverse environments.

As thousands of years passed, these earliest Americans spread across the North American continent, found their place and became independent. These tribes and bands of hunters and gatherers formed their own unique cultures and spoke their own languages.

In Texas, the Native Americans lived successfully for nine or ten

or no one really knows how many thousands of years before the

Europeans came. The Native Americans not only survived here but

adapted to changes in the climate and increased in numbers. They

developed new tools and ways over time. However, they did all this without major damage or changes to the environment.

More seems to be known about the Karankawa than the other

groups because they were the ones that Cabeza de Vaca first met.

Of the coastal Indians, the Karankawas managed to stay alive

longer than the rest.

You and your research team will be investigating to learn more about the people who lived along the coast among the bays, lagoons, marshes, river deltas and prairies of the central coastal zone.

Materials: none

Procedure:

1. The Karankawas shared some of the customs of other Texas coastal Indians, but physically, they were different. This was first recorded by Cabeza de Vaca. On November 6, 1528, he and his crew were slammed onto the Texas coast by a Gulf storm. The exact location of this first meeting of the Karankawa and the Spaniards is not known. It is believed to be somewhere on the far west end of Galveston Island. The Spaniards were soon surrounded by the Karankawa with long bows and sharp arrows wanting to get back the earthen pot, small dog and a few fish they had stolen from a nearby hut. In his journal, Cabeza de Vaca notes that they were surrounded by more than a hundred Indian bowmen, “who if they were not large, our fears made giants of them. . .”

© 2002 Texas Sea Grant College Program

Table 1: Nutritional Value of Meats in Karankawa Diet at Shoreline Sites

Animal K calories Protein (grams) Fat (grams) Carbohydrates (grams)
Mammal (deer) 126 26.0 4.0 0
Fish (average) 93 17.8 3.14 0
Mollusks (average) 78 12.8 1.5 2.3
Bird (wild duck) 233 21.1 15.8 0

NOTE: All values are 100 grams of raw meat weight

From other sources it is clear that the Karankawas were unusually tall for Native Americans. Men were often near six feet or reached six feet in height. They were also noted for their strong and robust physiques. Measurements of skeletons found in a coastal prehistoric cemetery indicated heights around six feet. The Karankawas were taller than other Native Americans and the Spaniards. It was also noted that the skeletons were healthy, strong, and hardy. The bones indicated that the muscles attached to them were strong. Another observation was that the skeletons from the Karankawas showed less stress than those of the inland Indians. The Karankawas bones were stronger and their bones did not show the effects of any deficiencies in diet (minerals or proteins). Based on these observations, what inferences can you make about their lifestyle?

2. The sources of nutrition and energy in human diets are proteins, fats and carbohydrates. Proteins are the major building blocks of body tissue. Carbohydrates supply most of the body’s energy needs. Fats and oils are highly concentrated sources of energy. Using archeological data, the nutritional value of the Karankawa diet at the shoreline sites was determined. The values of the nutrients per 100 grams of raw meat for each of the major meats they ate are given in Table 1.

a.
What percentage of their diet was protein?

b.
What percentage was fat?

c.
What percentage were carbohydrates?

  1. What statement could you make about the supply of protein, carbohydrates, and fat in the Karankawan diet?

  2. How do the nutrients provided by the Karankawan diet compare to the nutrient intake in your diet?

  3. Generally, various human diets worldwide involve only about 10 to 25 percent protein and most modern diets are made up largely

Lien: Investigating the Marine Environment in the 21st Century

of carbohydrates from which most of the energy is obtained. It is probable that humans cannot survive on a sustained diet consisting of more than 40 to 50 percent protein. This amount of protein would result in “protein poisoning” from the excess nitrogen. What might the Karankawa have eaten that would have provided fat and carbohydrates to balance the high protein diet?

    1. Cabeza de Vaca in his journal stated, “From October through February every year, which is the season these Indians live on the Island, they subsist on the roots I have mentioned, which the women get from under the water in November and December. Only in these two months, too, do they fish in cane weirs. When the fish is consumed, the roots furnish the staple. At the end of February, the islanders go to other parts to seek sustenance for the root is beginning to grow and is not edible.”

    2. Based on Cabeza de Vaca’s journal what may have helped offset the high amount of proteins in the Karankawa’s diet?
    1. Jean Beranger, a French navigator who sailed from Louisiania in 1720, to the area of Aransas Pass wrote about a large shoreline camp at Aransas Pass, near Corpus Christi Bay that he visited in late October. “I was surprised, since I least expected to see in a moment a large market town build of these kinds of houses (hide-covered huts) and five hundred

    2. persons , at least, well sheltered. The descriptions by Beranger leaves no doubt that this was a Karankawan camp. He also reported, “They have a small permanent village of about a dozen large, quite round huts. That is where they put the supply for the winter that consists of fish that they dry without salt.” Beranger also made some interesting notes on their diet: “Although they do not cultivate the soil, they eat bread …they make with acorns, ashes, fibrous plant well crushed and pounded together and cook it over live coals. I ate some of it solely to oblige, but it is nasty eating according to my way of thinking. The rest of their food is fish that they eat half raw, a great deal of roots, and oysters.” What does Beranger’s report tell us about the diet of the Karankawa?
  1. A species of cattail is salt-tolerant and grows in the shallow bays and lagoons along the Texas coast. These roots are high in fiber and are mostly a carbohydrate starch. They are edible until mid- winter. Also acorns from live oak trees have low tannic acid and are available in the fall. The acorns are about 72 percent carbohydrates, 19 percent fats, and 9 percent protein. In the prairie regions, fruits of plants such as mustang grape, prickly pear, persimmon, berries, anacua, hackberry, and mesquite beans were available in the spring and summer.

© 2002 Texas Sea Grant College Program

These fruits provide carbohydrates in the form of fructose or starch. Based on Cabeza de Vaca’s journal, Beranger’s report and what is known about plants along the coast, what inferences could be made about the diet of the Karankawas?

  1. Why were the Karankawa taller, stronger, and healthier than the other Native Americans and the Spaniards? Based on the descriptions of the Karankawa diet and nutrition, what conclusion could be made about the relationship of diet and size and strength of the Karankawa? Explain.

  2. Why did the Karankawas survive longer than many other Indians after the colonists began settlements in coastal Texas?

  3. The Karankawas were non-agricultural people who relied on gathering, hunting, and fishing for their food. What does their diet show us about the so-called “primitive” people’s knowledge of their environment and survival skills? Were they primitive people? Explain.

  4. Summarize your conclusion about the Karankawas below.

Lien: Investigating the Marine Environment in the 21st Century


Texas Sea Grant College Program | 2700 Earl Rudder Freeway South, Suite 1800 | College Station, Texas 77845.

phone: 979.845.3854 | fax: 979.845.7525 | Customer Service | Webmaster
Last Modified: 09/14/06